Employee Rights ยท Worker Classification
Employee or Independent Contractor in California? Apply the ABC Test Step by Step
In California, the starting assumption is that you are an employee. A business that pays you as an independent contractor generally has to prove otherwise, and for most jobs it does that using a three-part standard known as the ABC test. Your title, a 1099 form, or a signed contractor agreement does not settle the question. What matters is how the work actually happens. Take the steps below in order.
Our recommendation: if you suspect you were classified the wrong way, ask a firm that represents workers to review it. LA Law Online refers readers to the employee misclassification lawyers at Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights (LFECR), who handle these cases on contingency.
Why California Evaluates Misclassification Under the ABC Test
Employee misclassification may be evaluated under California's ABC test, which the state Supreme Court adopted in the 2018 Dynamex decision and the Legislature wrote into law through Assembly Bill 5, now found in Labor Code section 2775 and the sections after it. Under the test, you are treated as an employee unless the hiring business shows that all three conditions below are true. Failing any one of them generally means employee status. LFECR's glossary explains the ABC test and the history of AB 5 if you want more background.
Step 1 (Part A): Are You Free From the Company's Control?
Ask whether the business controls and directs how you do the work, both under your agreement and in practice. Signs of control include:
- Set shifts or required hours chosen by the company.
- Rules on how to perform each task, scripts, or required training.
- Performance reviews, discipline, or the ability to fire you at will.
If the company runs your day the way it runs an employee's day, Part A is probably not met.
Step 2 (Part B): Is Your Work Outside the Company's Usual Business?
This is often the deciding question. A plumber hired once to fix a leak at a clothing store is doing work outside the store's usual business. A delivery driver for a delivery company, or a stylist at a salon, is usually doing the very work the business sells. If what you do is a core part of what the company offers customers, Part B is generally not met.
Step 3 (Part C): Do You Run Your Own Independent Business?
The question here is whether you are customarily engaged in an independently established trade or business of the same kind. Evidence might include your own business license, other clients, marketing to the public, your own insurance, and the freedom to set prices. Someone who works only for one company, and became a "contractor" because that company required it, usually falls short.
One client, company schedule, company tools, work that is central to the business.
Many clients, your own rates, your own equipment, work that is outside the hiring company's line of business.
Step 4: Check Whether an Exemption Sends You to the Borello Test
The ABC test is the default, not the only rule. AB 5 and later amendments exempt a long list of occupations and business arrangements. Examples include certain licensed professionals such as doctors, lawyers and accountants, some business-to-business relationships, licensed real estate agents, and some creative and professional services that meet specific conditions. For exempt work, status is generally decided by the older Borello test, which weighs many factors, with the right to control the work as the most important.
Being in an exempt category does not mean you are a contractor. It only means a different test applies, and many workers are still employees under Borello.
Step 5: Add Up What Misclassification May Cost You
Misclassifying a worker as an independent contractor may deprive that worker of overtime pay and other employee benefits. Protections that may be missing include:
- Minimum wage and overtime, including California's daily overtime rules.
- Meal and rest breaks, with premium pay when they are not provided.
- Expense reimbursement for mileage, phone use and required equipment.
- Unemployment and disability insurance through the state's EDD unemployment program.
- Workers' compensation if you are hurt on the job, and paid sick leave.
A misclassified worker may also be paying the employer's share of payroll taxes through self-employment tax. The independent contractor misclassification glossary entry covers the common remedies, and the state's Labor and Workforce Development Agency oversees the departments that enforce classification rules.
Why We Recommend LFECR for Classification Questions
We recommend Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights because classification disputes usually pit a single worker against a business with more resources. According to the firm, it represents employees and consumers exclusively and never employers, works on contingency with no fee unless there is a recovery, was founded in 2015, and serves all 58 California counties from its Burbank headquarters. Managing Partner Robert Ebert Byrnes heads its litigation, and help is available in English and Spanish.
Not Sure How the Test Applies to Your Job?
A free case review can walk through your contract and day-to-day work.
Check My ClassificationLA Law Online (lalawonline.net) offers general information about California employment law. This explainer is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Worker classification depends on specific facts, and exemptions have detailed conditions that change over time. Speak with a qualified California employment attorney about your own work arrangement.