Employee Rights ยท Misclassification
Misclassified as an Independent Contractor in California? Seven Steps to Take Next
Realizing you may have been an employee all along, even though you were paid on a 1099, raises a practical question: what now? The answer is a sequence. Confirm the classification problem, work out what it may have cost you, gather proof, choose where to bring a claim, and protect yourself along the way. This explainer lays that sequence out in seven steps.
The direct answerStart by writing down how the work was actually controlled and collecting your contracts, 1099s, invoices, pay records and messages. Then total your hours and expenses, consider a wage claim with the California Labor Commissioner or a lawsuit, file for unemployment if the work has ended, and talk to an employment lawyer before you sign any new agreement or release.
Our recommendation: have a worker-side firm look at your arrangement before you take steps that are hard to undo. LA Law Online refers readers to the employee misclassification attorneys at Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights (LFECR), who handle these claims on contingency.
Step 1: Employee Misclassification May Be Evaluated Under California's ABC Test (AB 5)
How do you know you were misclassified? Under California's ABC test, written into law by AB 5 and now found in Labor Code sections 2775 and following, a worker is generally presumed to be an employee unless the hiring business shows all three of these:
- A: the worker is free from its control and direction;
- B: the work is outside the usual course of its business; and
- C: the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade or business of that kind.
Some occupations and business relationships are exempt and are judged under an older multi-factor standard known as the Borello test, and app-based drivers are covered by separate rules under Proposition 22. A lawyer can tell you which standard may apply.
You signed a contractor agreement. Does that matter?
Not by itself. A label or a signed contractor agreement generally does not decide status; how the work is actually done does. Keep the agreement anyway, since it is part of the record.
Step 2: See How Misclassifying You as an Independent Contractor May Have Deprived You of Overtime Pay and Other Employee Benefits
What could you be owed? Depending on the facts, a misclassified worker may be owed some combination of the items below. LFECR's glossary entry on independent contractor misclassification explains the concept in more detail.
| What may be owed | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Minimum wage and overtime | Pay for hours worked that a flat rate or per-job fee did not cover |
| Meal and rest break premium pay | Premium pay when required breaks were not provided |
| Business expense reimbursement | Necessary costs of doing the job, under Labor Code section 2802 |
| Itemized wage statements | The pay records employees are generally entitled to receive |
| Access to state programs | Unemployment and disability insurance, and workers' compensation |
Willful misclassification can also carry civil penalties under Labor Code section 226.8.
Failing to pay legally required overtime may create a wage and hour claim
Where a misclassified worker put in long weeks at a flat rate, unpaid overtime may be a large part of the picture. The federal Fair Labor Standards Act also sets overtime rules; which law fits a particular claim is a question for a lawyer.
Hypothetical example. A delivery worker paid as a contractor spent $75 a month on a phone plan used to receive dispatches and $45 a month renting a hand truck the company required, for 20 months.
$75 plus $45 is $120 a month. $120 times 20 months is $2,400 in costs that may be reimbursable as necessary business expenses, before any unpaid wages are counted. Whether each cost qualifies depends on the facts.
Step 3: Gather the Records That Show How the Work Really Worked
Payroll and timekeeping records may support a wage claim
- Write down how the work was controlled. Who set your schedule, gave instructions, required tools or uniforms, and set your rates.
- Keep the paperwork. 1099s, contracts, invoices, pay records and messages with the company.
- Total your hours. Use app logs, texts, calendars or your own notes to rebuild the time you worked.
- Save copies somewhere you control, where that is lawful, in case your access to company systems ends.
Step 4: Weigh a Labor Commissioner Claim Against a Lawsuit
An administrative claim with the California Labor Commissioner. The state's Labor and Workforce Development Agency site points to the state's labor departments.
A civil case filed in court. Which route fits generally depends on the claims involved, so a lawyer can help you compare.
Step 5: If the Work Has Ended, Look Into Unemployment
Can you get unemployment? Possibly. Misclassified workers may have access to programs such as unemployment insurance. If the work has ended, you can file an unemployment claim with the EDD, and the EDD decides whether you are eligible.
Step 6: Know Your Protection and Watch the Clock
Will you get in trouble for raising it? Retaliation for raising misclassification or wage complaints is generally unlawful. How long do you have? Wage claims under the Labor Code generally have three years, but some claims and penalties have shorter or longer limits, so a lawyer should check yours.
Step 7: Talk to a Lawyer Before You Sign Anything New
If the company offers a new contract, a settlement or a release, get advice first, because signing could affect what you are able to recover. Questions about taxes on past 1099 income should go to a tax professional.
Does it cost money to talk to a lawyer? Not with the firm we recommend. Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights represents employees and consumers exclusively, never employers, and lists misclassification among its practice areas. According to the firm, it was founded in 2015, works on contingency with no fee unless there is a recovery, and offers a free case review in English or Spanish. It is headquartered in Burbank, says it serves all 58 California counties, and its Head of Litigation is Managing Partner Robert Ebert Byrnes.
Find Out What Your Classification May Have Cost You
A free case review can look at your agreement, your hours and your expenses together.
Request a Misclassification ReviewLA Law Online (lalawonline.net) offers general information about California employment law. This explainer is not legal advice or tax advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Worker status, what may be owed and the deadlines that apply depend on the facts and on exemptions that change over time. Speak with a qualified California employment attorney about your own work arrangement.